A guide for Nonprofits, Associations, and Foundations to Strengthen community connections and audience engagement.
Looking for fresh ways to rethink your annual report? We've turned this blog into a free guide packed with insights and inspirations to help you take your next big step. Click here to download the guide and have a copy of your own.
Many organizations consider the annual report an obligatory exercise or sometimes just a legal requirement. While your organization may have been treating this document as a bland affair, it can be a valuable asset. Using our decades of experience helping passion-driven organizations, we have compiled some considerations that can transform the process and final product.
The American Academy of Periodontology Foundation(AAPF) – ANNUAL REPORT
What is an Annual Report? Proof you’re crushing it every year.
An annual report is like a yearbook for your nonprofit, association, or foundation, showcasing everything you’ve accomplished over the past year. It’s a polished document filled with stories, statistics, and financials that tell the world (and your supporters) how you’ve been making a difference. Think of it as a way to spotlight your mission in action!
Why publish an Annual Report?
Publishing an annual report sends the message that you’re organized, accountable, and proud of what you’re doing. It’s your chance to shout, “Look what we did together!” while laying the foundation for more support and growth in the future. Plus, it’s a great resource to keep on hand when applying for grants or pitching to sponsors—proof of your credibility and dedication!
How can it benefit your organization?
An annual report isn’t just a nice summary—it’s a powerful tool. It helps you:
- Build trust by being transparent with donors, stakeholders, and the public.
- Celebrate successes and highlight the real impact your organization is having.
- Inspire future donations by showing exactly where contributions go and the difference they make.
- Engage new partners with a compelling narrative of your goals and achievements.
Tip #1: Up Your Game
Change the name to up your game.
A name can signal a lot to both your external and internal audience. In many ways, it sets the tone for your communication. Sure, “annual report” is an apt description, but it isn’t going to solicit much of a reaction. Does it really indicate what your organization has accomplished in the past year? Think about the mission and goals of the organization. Think about the ultimate goal of this document.
If your goal is to showcase the fantastic impact of your mission, why not call it an “Impact Report”?
Want to shine a spotlight on how much you appreciate your donors? Try a “Gratitude Report.”
The idea is to match the name with the purpose of the document. Tailor it to resonate with both your staff and your audience. Think of it as naming a star—make sure it reflects the bright, shining achievements within!
AgeOptions "Year in Review" – The title of this report, “Year in Review,” highlights the accomplishments of the organization over the past year, while the theme, “Celebrating Inclusion,” focuses on this year’s story.
Tip #2: Consider Your Audience
Consider your key audiences when making creative choices.
Before diving into your usual routine or pinging finance and program managers for those end-of-year figures, take a moment to hit pause and gain a fresh perspective.
Picture yourself in the shoes of your key audiences—whether that’s donors, agency funders, volunteers, executive leadership, or the general public. Write down the top one or two audiences you’re aiming to impress. Now, think about what they’d really want to know. What will help them feel good about their support? Where do they need to see transparency? How can you show that their contributions are making a tangible impact?
Once you’ve got those insights, craft a compelling story that aligns with their needs. It’s all about proving to them that their trust and support are appreciated and making a real difference.
The Josselyn Center "A Map of our Journey" – The Josselyn Center shares its road to recovery by adopting the structure of a roadmap, highlighting landmarks and milestones achieved over the past year. By considering the perspective of its clients, the Center offers donors a closer look at the positive impact it has had on community wellness.
Tip #3: Change Hearts and Minds
Compelling stories can change hearts and minds.
Stories have the power to stick with people long after the details fade. In the nonprofit world, they’re your secret weapon! Let’s face it: stats are great, but stories? They tug at the heartstrings. They’re what turn a one-time donor into a lifelong supporter. So, when crafting your annual report, don’t just stop at numbers—bring the real-life impact to life. Here’s how:
Showcase where impact is happening.
Let your stories put a spotlight on the lives you’ve touched. You’re not just moving numbers around a spreadsheet—you’re moving hearts. People love to hear about the direct impact their support is making. These stories are your chance to make that personal, emotional, and memorable connection.
Franciscan Outreach – Annual Report
Changing Lives, One Step at a Time
Meet Kenneth, a father who found himself homeless after several unfortunate events. Kenneth lost both his legs after he was struck in a hit-and-run auto accident. With nowhere else to go, he turned to our community shelter, a wheelchair-accessible facility. It enabled Kenneth to be fully mobile. With the help of his Franciscan Outreach case manager, Kenneth was able to become housing-ready and transition to permanent supportive housing. Thanks to the generous support from donors, Kenneth is now working, has a place to call home, and is giving back by volunteering with us.
One Story of Need: The Journey Continues.
But there’s still more to be done. For every success, there is another person waiting for help.
Take John Brooks, for example—a Chicago-raised photographer who struggled to find a safe place to live. Although he worked as a freelancer, he couldn’t seem to make enough money to live on his own. Eventually, John became homeless. When outreach workers approached him about staying at Franciscan Outreach’s new shelter in the Pilsen neighborhood, John was eager to find some stability in his life.
At the shelter, John participates in support group meetings each week. He also has regular meetings with his case manager, who is helping him find job opportunities and connect with other critical resources. With your continued generosity, John’s story can have a brighter ending.
The need continues, and the story isn’t over. The good news? You have the power to help write the next chapter.
Tell a Compelling story each year.
Each year, you’re doing incredible work—don’t let it go untold! Make storytelling a staple of your annual report. It’s not just about showcasing what you’ve done; it’s about engaging your audience in the ongoing narrative of your mission. After all, what’s more compelling than a great story? One that changes lives.
Tip #4: First Impressions Matter
Presentation is Everything.
Ever heard the saying, “Actions speak louder than words?” Well, in the nonprofit world, presentation speaks just as loudly as your mission statement. How you visually present your organization is just as important as what you say. Everything—from your photos to your printing choices— should send a consistent message.
First impressions matter: Are you helping or hurting your mission?
Before anyone reads a word of your annual report, they’re already forming opinions based on how it looks. The design, the photos, the quality of the materials—all of these details communicate whether or not you’re a professional, trustworthy organization. When you put care into these elements, you’re essentially saying, “We’re serious about our mission, and we’ve got the skills to make things happen.” So, critically examine how you’re visually presenting your organization. Is it polished? Does it reflect the level of sophistication and professionalism that inspires confidence? If not, it’s time to level up!
Photography – This professionally photographed portrait engages the viewer by breaking the subject out of the traditional pose and using selective focus to help us connect with the researcher’s passion.
Are your pictures worth a thousand likes?
Sure, we’ve all snapped a quick cell phone photo in the moment, but let’s be honest: blurry, poorly lit images just don’t scream, “We’re doing important work!” They can actually detract from your message. Want to help your audience connect with the people and communities you’re serving? Invest in high-quality photography whenever you can. Whether hiring a professional or finding a talented volunteer, capturing beautiful, compelling images is worth it. Good photos tell stories, spark emotions, and bring your impact to life in a way that words alone can’t.
Elevate your game and add special printing techniques.
Sometimes, it’s all about the little things that make people go, “Wow!” That’s where specialty printing comes in. A unique and eye-catching cover can be the difference between your annual report being tossed in a pile or immediately opened with curiosity. Whether it’s a die-cut window, embossed elements, or textured paper, these details grab attention and send the message that your organization is a cut above. When your audience holds something that feels special, they’ll sense that your mission is special, too.
So, remember—every aspect of your presentation should have a consistent message.
Tip#5: Question Your Avenues of Delivery
Question your avenues of delivery.
When it comes to sharing your annual report, you’ve got more options than ever before! From traditional print to interactive digital experiences, how you deliver your message can be just as important as the message itself. So, let’s dive into the options and help you choose the best way to deliver your story—because, after all, how you tell it matters just as much as what you tell!
The traditional printed book.
There’s something classic about holding a beautifully designed, printed annual report in your hands. It’s perfect for telling the whole story—financials, donor lists, and all the nitty-gritty details. But here’s the catch: your printed report needs to be as polished as your mission. Think top-notch design, high-quality imagery (photos or illustrations), and printing that feels like a million bucks. You want readers to feel the care and effort that went into creating the report because that reflects the care you put into your mission.
The abbreviated printed booklet: Short, sweet, and budget-friendly.
If the budget is tight but you still want something physical to share, an abbreviated printed booklet could be your best friend. Focus on the core messages and themes of the year—your top achievements, heartwarming stories, and key goals for the future. You don’t need to cram in every detail, like financials or board member lists (you can save those for the PDF version or a webpage). This is all about giving readers the emotional highlights and leaving them wanting more.
AgeOptions Flip Book – "Year in Review"
The PDF: Flexible and eco-friendly.
Want all the space of a traditional report without breaking the bank or using up a forest’s worth of paper? PDFs are your solution. They’re as long (or short!) as you need them to be, and the best part? You can embed links, videos, or presentations, turning your annual report into a multimedia experience! Easily upload it to your website or email it to your supporters, and you’re good to go. You can even create a PDF version of your printed report, offering the best of both worlds.
Bonus Tip
Bonus tip: Nailing your content approach (like a carpenter!)
Your annual report is more than just a recap—it’s your story, your mission, and your future all rolled into one. So, how do you approach it in a way that makes your audience feel like they’re part of something bigger? Here’s a blueprint to keep things fresh, engaging, and impactful:
Start with the storytelling: Bring your mission to life.
Begin with the heart of your organization—your story and the specific impact you’re making. People love stories, especially when they’re authentic, emotional, and inspiring. Introduce readers to the people or communities you’ve helped and show them the tangible difference their support has made. This is your chance to connect your audience to your mission from the first sentence.
Goals: Where are you heading?
Next, touch on the road ahead. What’s the vision for the future? Where is your organization headed, and what are your big, bold goals for next year (and beyond)? This keeps people excited and invested in your ongoing journey. After all, your mission isn’t over—it’s just getting started!
Cook County Bureau of Economic Development – Annual Report
Keep program descriptions short & sweet.
While it is tempting to dive deep into every program detail, save the full brochure for another time. Use short, snappy descriptions of your programs that highlight the core purpose without overwhelming readers. Keep it tight—just enough for people to understand the value without losing their attention. Think of it as the elevator pitch version of your programs.
Show the impact: Numbers + Narratives.
Remember to sprinkle in some hard facts! Whether it’s the number of meals served, children educated, or trees planted, impact stats are key. And, of course, people want to know how their dollars are being used. Give a clear, concise overview of your financials, showing how funds are being allocated toward your mission. Transparency is key—let your audience see how you maximize resources and why they can trust you with their support.
Build trust: Be Transparent & Accountable.
Speaking of trust, your annual report is the perfect place to be open and honest. Show how you’re accountable for every dollar received and how it’s being used to accomplish incredible things. The more transparent you are, the more people will feel justified in supporting you. They want to know their contributions make a real difference, so give them every reason to believe you’re the best steward of their generosity.
Get a pro: Hire an outside writer to polish your story.
You’re great at what you do—changing lives, running programs, and leading the charge for good. But sometimes, it’s best to bring in a fresh set of eyes to polish up your narrative. A professional writer can help shape your stories, make sure your messaging shines, and ensure your report is compelling and crystal clear. Who doesn’t love a good wordsmith making your work sound even more amazing?
Sigma Alpha Epsilon – Annual Report Print
Don’t forget the CTAs: Invite them to join in.
An annual report is not just about reflection—it’s about action! Be sure to include clear calls-to-action throughout. Let your audience know how they can get involved, whether it’s a simple “Donate” button, a link to volunteer opportunities, or an invite to follow your social media pages. This is your chance to turn readers into doers—make it easy for them to take the next step!
Wrap it all up: Your Content, Your Story, Your Impact.
Approach your annual report like the powerful communication tool it is. Lead with stories, highlight your goals, be transparent, and make it easy for people to take action. If you are in doubt, get some help polishing it up. With this thoughtful approach, your content won’t just inform—it’ll inspire, engage, and build lasting connections.
American Academy of Periodontology Foundation – Annual Report Featured above is a spread dedicated to thanking donors for their continued support.
Must-have items for your annual report.
- Letter from the Top Brass: A heartfelt note from your Executive Director and Board Chair.
- Mission & Vision: Show off your guiding stars and where you’re headed.
- Strategic Goals: Lay out your roadmap and how you’re gearing up for future victories. Confidence is key!
- Achievements & Impact: Share your triumphs with flair— numbers, stories, and visuals like infographics and photos.
- Donor Insights: What do your supporters need to know to keep the faith? Make sure it’s crystal clear.
- Financial Snapshot: Break down your revenue, funding sources, and expenses. Show how wisely you’re using the resources entrusted to you.
- Gratitude Galore: A big thank you to all supporters, donors, sponsors, and volunteers—if they’ve given the thumbs-up for public shout-outs.
Schedule an appointment to discuss your annual report today! Send a message to info@neigerdesign.com to get started. And don't forget to take these ideas with you! Click here to download the guide and have a copy of your own.
Comments
Questions or comments? Join the conversation!